Here's a closer look at GOSH plush Tails from 2009.
This shows that he does have his glove cuff details, colored shoe bottoms & the fur at the edges of his face is stuffed. The bangs are an interesting super-thick solid felt shape. The body seems a decent shape/size and his face looks to have good proportion as well. This is actually a pretty solid looking plush when viewed from a normal angle. The ruler at the bottom shows that this is likely over 10 inches tall, so a fair size at least.