At left is Toy Network's 12 inch size Amy modern plush. It's pretty standard fare for them, not great, but not terrible. The eye color pieces are somewhat too large as well as the black eye lash 'edges' but that's common to the brand, as are the somewhat withered hands. She's nothing super, but not mutant either.

Mystery classic Amy plush!
What company made this small size Amy? Notice her distinguishing feature: the laces are all PRINTED on. Other Amys have a bow, a ribbon, or all laced shoes. This one has printed-only details. The ears are flopped forward, but that's also common on cheaper small size plush where the pattern doesn't bother with a 3d ear. The dress, shirt & eyelash details are all normal. One arm seems a bit longer than the other. It's not a bad plush at all, but which company makes it?